Making Shutterfly's "Make it Fast" editor truly be fast

Overview

Reducing complexity without sacrificing features

Shutterfly is a market leader in customizable print-on-demand memorabilia, but contrary to it's reputation, their "Make it Fast" photo book editor creates a frustrating experience with it's unintuitive design. I explored ways to redesign the editor updating how tools were organized to create an interface users, new and old, could easily jump right into and start creating.

Focus

Role

User Research

User Testing

Prototyping

Highlights

Improved learnability for first time users

Increased Task Success Rate

15%

Increased First-Click Accuracy

20%

Project Goal

Improve Shutterfly’s "Make it Fast" photo book creation process by streamlining the editing experience

Heuristic Evaluation

What is the current "Make it Fast" experience?

Technical jargon obscures functionality

Users without a background in printing services would have no way of understanding what various features do.

Opportunity 1

Use more accessible language or tool tips

Heuristic Evaluation

What is the current "Make it Fast" experience?

Technical jargon obscures functionality

Users without a background in printing services would have no way of understanding what various features do.

Opportunity 1

Use more accessible language or tool tips

Heuristic Evaluation

What is the current "Make it Fast" experience?

Technical jargon obscures functionality

Users without a background in printing services would have no way of understanding what various features do.

Opportunity 1

Use more accessible language or tool tips

Qualitative Usability Tests

Users found the photo book editor a great idea, but they struggled with actually using it.

"It doesn't seem very intuitive."

"I don’t even know what 'embellishments' mean."

"There's a lack of explanation...

I don’t trust that."

The Challenge

How might we reorganize the photo book editing interface to improve learnability?

Redesign

An Organized Toolset

One Main Toolbar

Singular location for core tools

Clarifying icons and language

Responsive Toolbar

Shows tools based on selected item

Reduces clutter to provide focus

Outcomes

Improved usability metrics across the board

Benchmark Rate

76.3%

Redesign Rate

91.1%

Outcomes

Improved usability metrics across the board

Benchmark Rate

76.3%

Redesign Rate

91.1%

Outcomes

Improved usability metrics across the board

Benchmark Rate

76.3%

Redesign Rate

91.1%

Next Steps

Polishing the Autofill process

While this project focused on improving the editor, the "Make It Fast" offer still has room for improvement with it's Autofill feature. Additional user research will be necessary, but the investment will be pivotal in refining the entire user experience.

@ 2025 by Eurie Oh

7:43:58 AM

@ 2025 by Eurie Oh

7:43:58 AM

@ 2025 by Eurie Oh

7:43:58 AM